This was good... while it lasted. I've heard high praises for this eyeliner but it doesn't seem all that great to me.

The color I bought, Pecan Twist, is a very pretty brown with shimmers in it. It defined my eyes naturally and wasn't too harsh of a shade.

The liner glided onto my eyelids without pulling or tugging, and lasted a few hours on my eyelids. It definitely did not last a whole day, though. It has a smudger sort of tool at the end of the liner but I never used it.

These are the good things about this liner. However, it has a lot of downsides to it :(

First off, this eyeliner feels a little too soft!! Not a great feature for a delicate twist-up liner like this. After the first day or two of using this liner, a small chunk of it, maybe 1mm, fell off. It felt like a waste since it was such a new product, even though it was a small amount that broke.

Next, this liner's quantity of product is SO SMALL. Like, I was shocked when the pencil suddenly ended! I used it for barely two months, and it just wouldn't twist up anymore. Worse still, whatever tiny portion was left that I was going to use, pushed down into the pencil casing and refused to twist up again >___< Even though a tiny part of this liner broke off earlier, I don't think that amount would have extended its life for very long. As I mentioned earlier, this lasts a few hours on my lids but disappears almost completely before I even wash my face at the end of the day.

This is a decent liner, but the amount in it is so tiny it's slightly ridiculous. I've owned some eyeliners before this that cost just slightly more, yet have lasted almost a year with daily use. Also, it's a little too thin for the delicate formula, causing wasteful breakages. The product retracting into the packing without being able to retrieve it is also a waste :( I certainly won't be buying another one of this, but will go back to the liner type and brand I was using previous to this one.